Take the 2-minute tour ×
Anime & Manga Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for anime and manga fans. It's 100% free, no registration required.

On what basis were the clans formed in naruto?

The blood siblings Indra and Ashura are from different clans (Uchiha & Senju respectively)., whereas other siblings, e.g. Itachi and Sasuke are from the same clan (Uchiha).

The first shinobi who got chakra was Kaguya. So, technically whoever posesses chakra should've inherited it from her. In that case, all should be from the same clan.

Now, here's my long time doubt. How is it decided that Naruto is from the Uzumaki clan when his father is from the Namikaze family and has no clan?

Is a person's clan decided based on the abilities of the person? If yes, how is their ability evaluated right after they are born?

share|improve this question
    
Is this asking how the clan-belonging is decided? or is this asking how the clans formed? –  Vogel612 Jun 18 at 11:00
    
I guess the question covers both. –  Kaguya Otsutsuki Jun 18 at 11:10
    
@Vogel612 Thanks for fixing the question. Is there a namikaze clan ? I doubt that part. Check this –  Kaguya Otsutsuki Jun 19 at 11:45

2 Answers 2

As a competing answer to the one of @MadaraUchiha, here's my take.

The clan belonging is solved quite easily. The clan-belonging is given through the generations maternally.

This means what decides the clan is not the father, but the mother. In Naruto's case that is Kushina Uzumaki

Other than that, the naruto-wiki gives some nice information:

A clan (一族, Ichizoku; Literally meaning "family"), in the loosest sense of the term, refers to a family or group of shinobi who form a basic unit of a shinobi village. Majority of these clans were mercenary military forces even before the First Shinobi World War. [...] Membership in a clan is usually determined by blood relations and genetics, which is vital in the usage of kekkei genkai and secret techniques. [...] While clans may be composed of many individuals and extended families, many clans mentioned and seen in the series were somewhat limited to a nuclear family. Highlighting by me

It seems that the most clans seen, are just the mentioned nuclear families. This leads to the assumption, that one line of family that somewhen declared itself a clan is a clan. Some family lines had more offspring, and some had less. for example the Hyuuga-clan has multiple branch families, who are subordinate to the main family. The Uchiha clan on the other hand seems to just be loosely organized.

Some clans seem to have a definitive familiy head (Hyuuga, Akimichi, Nara). Other clans are not organized (Uchiha, Uzumaki, Inuzuka, [...]).

Clans mostly differ in chakra affinity and Kekkei Genkai, as well as battle style. In fact that seems to be the only thing shared in a clan. This Chakra affinity seems to be genetic, so that you are rather born into a clan than "join" it. It seems that not every person has his / her own clan, most prominent examples are probably Kakashi Hatake and Might Guy.

share|improve this answer

All humans came from the same ancestor ("Adam"), does that make us all family? Technically it does. Realistically, so much time had passed that no one looks at it that way.

This is the same. Based on the latest chapter, it indeed seems as though Hagoromo was the ancestor of the Uchiha and Senju clans, while Hamura (at least based on his eyes in the picture) was the ancestor of the Hyuuga clan.

That makes them all one big happy family, except that this history is long forgotten, and no one views it like that anymore.

As for clan ownership, Naruto belongs to the Uzumaki clan because his mother was from the Uzumaki clan. The Uzumaki is a subclan of the Senju, which is related to the Uchiha. Does that make Naruto an Uchiha? Not really.

Clan ownership is determined by birth, not ability.

share|improve this answer
    
I dont agree. Consider the adam's example. Adam and eve would've got children and grand children etc. A group of people among them could've migrated to different place. After several decades, they could've forgotten their baseline and formed different clans. This is a long process. How come direct blood brothers are from different clans ? –  Kaguya Otsutsuki Jun 18 at 10:45
    
Because each of them inherited different prowesses. They divided themselves from one another, and ended up being separated. The stone monument was the only thing that remained as history from that time. Also, shouldn't you know your own grandchildren? What kind of a grandma are you? –  Madara Uchiha Jun 18 at 10:46
2  
Lol, my grandchildren have forgotten their root and fighting with each other. That's why I am taking their chakra back. However two kids are trying to stop me, and you call them heroes?? Ridiculous :P –  Kaguya Otsutsuki Jun 18 at 10:54
2  
@KaguyaOtsutsuki I am tempted to upvote your question, solely for the fact that you killed our mod... –  Vogel612 Jun 18 at 10:56
    
Also: assuming that "Adam" actually existed and we didn't evolve from amobea (though we would just all come from amobea no. [..] and the point remains) ;) But I think that would be better fit for Christianity, Islam or Skeptics –  Vogel612 Jun 18 at 10:58

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.