Follow me here for a minute. The state is controlled by the homunculi/Father who wants people to use alchemy to do dangerous research especially human transmutation to make philosopher stones.

Why would they have laws that forbid it in their country? Seems counter productive to their goals.

  • 12
    Why is it illegal to kill, and yet it's legal to have wars? Aug 13, 2014 at 19:33
  • @MadaraUchiha Everything is legal if there is nobody around to punish you. Aug 15, 2014 at 21:19

2 Answers 2


@Madara basically hit the nail on the head here, but I thought I'd elaborate a bit.

Unmarked spoilers follow.

Father wants people making philosopher's stones for his goals. He has his end goal of the Nationwide Transmutation Circle, and he has a plan to get it. This plan involves the military laboratories (especially lab #5), as well as waging wars (such as the blood crest in the North), and a few other things.

But let's consider the very first episode of Brotherhood, in which Isaac McDougal, by way of philosopher's stone, launched an attack against the military, attempting to completely freeze over Central. This was clearly contrary to Father's goals, as its motive was to destroy Central by ice, beneath which Father lived.

Great Scott that's a lot of icicles!

And later in the series, the truth behind the military's law of, "you must not create humans," is revealed: they are not concerned with ethics, but rather to prevent people from creating an army which would oppose the government's, and subsequently, oppose Father.

So, like @Madara initially mentioned: killing people in reality is illegal, yet countries wage war because the governments have their own motives, which they believe are above those of the citizens. Yet, we can't just have citizens going around massacring others, can we? (Hint: The answer is no.)

  • 3
    Likewise you cannot transmute gold because that would create an economic instability. While bad for the general populace, the resulting instability might make Father's goals more difficult to attain.
    – uncle brad
    Aug 13, 2014 at 23:44

Morals predate father's existence he is only in his 5th century and its likely that some other person of greater moral fiber and less pride created the ethical system which was then codified into law. Fundamental principles of societies are hard to change when revolutions are hidden. Revisions to history, ethics and taboos would be extremely difficult to change. Just look at foot binding as an example of culture resisting an opposing government and even medicine.

  • 2
    True, but as noted by the other post, there are other significant reasons human transmutation is forbidden. (Notice that one of the two other rules that must be followed is "do not oppose the military" - it seems reasonable to conclude that these rules are formulated by the military, rather than necessarily morality.)
    – Maroon
    Aug 14, 2014 at 7:50

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .