7

We know that the Rinnegan is the next stage of Sharingan and since Madara can switch from Sharingan to Rinnegan and vice versa, why can't Nagato?

5

The Rinnegan is extremely rare and is considered as the most powerful among the Three Great Dojutsu. Before I get to my answer, it is necessary to look into other cases of dojutsu transplantation.

Kakashi Hatake

Kakashi received the Sharingan at a young age. He had years of experience with it and was considered a genius at the usage of Sharingan. He was even appointed to train Itachi and Sasuke Uchiha with their Sharingan development. Even with the amount of knowledge and power of the Sharingan, he couldn't revert the Sharingan back to its normal state. That was because of a simple reason: the eye wasn't his. It originally belonged to Obito Uchiha. Since Kakashi wasn't the original owner of the eye, he is unable to revert the eye back to normal.

From Kakashi Hatake wikia article:

Because he is not an Uchiha, Kakashi was unable to deactivate this dōjutsu.

The article tells us that, in order to deactivate the Sharingan, the person needs to be an Uchiha. This can also be related with Danzo Shimura and his arsenal of eyes.

Obito Uchiha

Obito "borrowed" the Rinnegan from Nagato, who originally got them from Madara Uchiha. There were many reasons why Obito implanted only one Rinnegan eye even after having obtained both. However, one of the main reasons was:

Under the guise of Madara and inheriting the former's work, Obito Uchiha claimed that he was entitled to take the Rinnegan from Nagato's body after his death. He then implanted the left Rinnegan into himself and hid the right Rinnegan, unable to handle the power of both eyes.

Since Obito wasn't the original owner of the eyes,

  1. He did not have complete mastery over it.
  2. He couldn't handle its overwhelming power.

Obito, being an Uchiha, lacked control over the Rinnegan. This kind of proves that an Uchiha cannot simply control the Rinnegan if he isn't the original owner. Keep in mind that Obito was trained by Madara himself.

Nagato

Nagato received the eyes at a very young age. He did not know that the Rinnegan were transplanted into him, and nor did he know that it evolved from a pair of Sharingan eyes. Nevertheless, he had almost complete mastery over them because:

  1. He was an Uzumaki and thus had huge chakra reserves.
  2. The eyes were implanted at a very young age, giving him time to perfect his Rinnegan skills by adulthood.

Sakurai Tomoki's answer is logical and makes sense. However, if we were to look at similarity between the Rinnegan (evolved from Sharingan) and the Sharingan itself, it seems that answer could be different.

We know from Kakashi's case that he couldn't deactivate the Sharingan because of its origins. We also know that Obito lacked control over the Rinnegan, which implies that he couldn't deactivate and revert it into a Sharingan. Combining these two factors, we can derive an explanation to the original question: Nagato couldn't revert the Rinnegan to Sharingan because he wasn't the eyes' original owner.

Madara displayed certain new and powerful techniques when he received his original eyes.

Because Madara was the eyes' original owner, only he could use them to their fullest power.

In many situations when the power of a borrowed dojutsu is questioned, the full potential of the eyes is always attained by the original owner. So it's logical to conclude that the Rinnegan to Sharingan swap was exclusive to Madara and not to the other two.

  • When I edit your answer, I find it weird that you assert the ownership to be the factor. Apart from Madara himself, there is no example of the eye being transplanted at young age to an Uchiha. From what I see, Kakashi and Nagato's cases are very similar (non-Uchiha, implanted for a long time), so shouldn't we able to get a conclusion from there? From your logic, I can see that Kakashi (+Nagato) and Obito's case shows Uchiha bloodline is not enough, and the person must have time to master the eyes. However, there is not enough proof to say that only the owner can revert the eye. – nhahtdh Mar 31 '15 at 14:54
  • ... Anyway, that is just my doubt looking at it from a logical perspective. I don't even follow the series myself. – nhahtdh Mar 31 '15 at 14:56
  • Well, because the Rinnegan in question was evolved from Sharingan. So I had to detail the answer in a way that covers both; Sharingan from Kakashi and Rinnegan from Obito. But I suppose you're right . The part about Obito doesn't contribute much. I'll edit that part out. And about the ownership, wiki states Kakashi's Sharingan couldn't revert the eye because of the ownership issue. Since the Rinnegan evolved from sharingan, I suppose the same principle works. Thanks for the edit btw :) – Ero Sɘnnin Mar 31 '15 at 15:06
  • @nhahtdh Oh I remembered just now.. The point of including Obito was to show that an Uchiha trained by Madara couldn't control it (revert it) , so how was a non-Uchiha supposed to do so. – Ero Sɘnnin Mar 31 '15 at 15:10
  • And about the ownership, wiki states Kakashi's Sharingan couldn't revert the eye because of the ownership issue. It seems what you cited only talk about the bloodline, though? – nhahtdh Mar 31 '15 at 15:15
0

The reason are most likely similar to Kakashi's Mangekyou Sharingan case. He just simply doesn't realize it. Nagato "awakens" his Rinnegan when his parents are murdered by the mistaken Konoha shinobi. But actually it was Uchiha Madara implanting it to him, not him awakening the Rinnegan. So, while he can use Rinnegan to great extend, he simply doesn't know that it was originated from the Sharingan and that he can revert it back to Sharingan.

This is the same as Kakashi. Although he has awakened his Mangekyou when he "killed" Rin, he simply doesn't realize that until years even though he was dubbed as a genius ninja.

Also it needs to be noted that the ones who knows about the Sharingan can be upgraded into Rinnegan are those who has awakened the Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan and read the stone tablet in the Uchiha underground hideout using Sharingan, Mangekyou Sharingan and Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan in order. Nagato, being a non-Uchiha and lived far away from Konoha, would have no knowledge of this.

protected by Community Sep 6 at 22:26

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.