11

In Sword Art Online, why did Akihiko Kayaba make the game so as to make death permanent? Don't get me wrong, I know that in episode 1 he claims that he would like to "control this world's fate". However, in episode 17, when he says that he "wanted to make a world free of laws and restrictions", then why make it so that people must die in real life as well? Wouldn't that make a real death contrary to his goals? And if he "forgot" somewhere in the middle of the game (as he claims in episode 14), what is the point in continuing further? Has he no regard for human life?

  • "to make a world free of laws and restrictions" does not necessarily mean a world without death and if he truly wanted a world free or laws and restrictions he would make towns safe zone where people can not be killed. also i think i remember at the end of the Aincrad Arc him mentioning he wanted the consequences of death to apply in the virtual world. – Memor-X Feb 6 '15 at 2:37
  • 2
    true freedom can only be known by those who have been deprived of it – ton.yeung Feb 6 '15 at 2:42
  • @Memor-X To be fair, I checked episode 14 multiple times when he was discussing what would become of Aincrad with Kirito and Asuna, along with checking the battle before once, just to make sure. There is no reference to him mentioning that he wanted "the consequences of death to apply in the virtual world." Also, having checked other posts, I realize that you, too, have only seen the anime, rather than both reading the novels and watching the anime. This means that unless you find it somewhere else in SAO, it is likely possible that you heard it from somewhere outside of canon SAO. – Samuel Langhus Feb 6 '15 at 4:01
  • (Continuing the previous comment) Also, if he wanted the consequences of death to apply, then why would he save Asuna? (As it is a different question, being answered multiple times, and most commenters are leaning towards him or Sugo preventing her death, my question may be incorrectly stated.) However, if he DID save her, why would he toss off his "wanting those consequences of death to apply" for saving a life? Then, after answering that, read my last question: Has he no regard for human life? If so, what makes Asuna and Kirito exempt from his desires? How are they different? – Samuel Langhus Feb 6 '15 at 4:14
  • @SamuelLanghus according to the wikia "Akihiko had a level of honor and fairness.", he did promise Kirito to make sure Asuna didn't commit suicide before the duel, she did just that. anyway to be honest i can't remember where i interpreted those lines (given it's been quite a while i've seen the series) but i havn't seen anything outside the anime to avoid spoiling the second season and no other MMO based anime had a figure like Kayaba so i had to have gotten it SAO – Memor-X Feb 6 '15 at 4:16
6

Okay, this question raises way to many personal opinions and speculations. It's never explained why perma-death was enabled in Sword Art Online. We'll also never find out since Kayaba Akihiko died.

First, I'd like to note that the perma-death was neither a law nor restriction, it was a rule, and thus Kayaba Akihiko did not go against any rules he set for SAO. Obviously, a game will have rules, so you'll have things like: death, no flying, max health, etc. What Kayaba Akihiko was referring to was a world without the laws and restrictions placed by the society in real life. That's my speculation, but that's all it could truly point to. Naturally, there are no laws or restrictions regarding death in SAO or IRL, but rather it's a fundamental rule.

From Kayaba Akihito's entry on Sword Art Online Wikia:

Kayaba Akihiko had little to no empathy, with no regard for human life (including his own)

Akihiko seemed to be very sincere and thoughtful, as shown when he told Kirito of his dream about creating a floating castle as the basis for creating Sword Art Online.

In spite of this, Akihiko had a level of honor and fairness. [...]

If you look at those three lines, we can also take something else from this. At the end of Sword Art Online Asuna dies, right? Wrong. Kayaba Akihiko made the promise to Kirito to prevent Asuna from committing suicide before the match was over (episode 13). He made this promise because he is both sincere and fair. Therefore, while Asuna did indeed die in the game, she didn't die in real life because of the promise Kayaba Akihiko made with Kirito. This is also why, as promised at the beginning of the series, all 6147 players were returned to the real world after Kirito completed SAO. Quoted from the anime: (Kayaba Akihiko) "Moments ago, all 6147 remaining players were successfully logged out."

Getting back to the point, everything Kayaba Akihiko did was not contrary to the goals he set and had in mind through out Sword Art Online. Everything fell into place and he didn't violate any of his rules. He fulfilled his dream and simply brought others into it, the idea was that Kayaba Akihiko wanted to replace the real world with virtual reality for himself. This is shown in the anime episode 14 at 18:41, when Kayaba Akihiko said, "I wanted to leave the Earth behind and go to that castle. For a long, long time that was my only desire." Naturally, since he made the game available to everyone, the rules he believed in and set for himself would have to be followed everyone else as well.

0

As Kayaba says (I doesn't remember when), "There's no difference between IRL and SAO." If you die, it happens on both ends. I think it was to induce psychological effect.

In Volume 1 - Chapter 24 of the light novel, during the scene where Kirito and Kayaba had a talk before they returned to reality:

“…What about those who died? Both of us are already dead, yet we continue to exist here. Doesn’t that mean you can return the other four thousand dead to the original world as well?”

Kayaba’s expression didn’t change. He closed the window, put his hands into his pockets, and then said:

“Life can’t be recovered so easily. Their consciousness will never return. The dead will disappear — this fact remains true in every world. I created this place only because I wanted to talk with you two — one last time.”

The difference is "a world free of laws and restrictions". You can change or remove some restrictions. For example, in real life, you cannot fight continuously for 20 hours, nor can you jump more than 20 meters. You can change some laws or some restrictions, but there are some basic things that you cannot change. Or, at least, you need some time to gradually get used to it.

Another example are Asuna's words. She told Kirito about male and female genitals. They weren't present in early version, but because of psychological effect, they were added in later version during Beta testing phase, but without any hair (because lack of effect, I think).

You can read this in Volume 1 - Chapter 16.5 (this special is in the web version only):

There is a somewhat interesting story concerning all of this (I apologize for digressing, but)... When SAO was under development, the Argas company had an internal closed alpha test phase during which time they reasoned that since players would have no use for genitals, it would not be necessary to objectify it.

However, in reality they found that most of the male testers would experience a certain amount of severe anxiety. Even so, while there was no problem when playing for several hours. When they conducted consecutive tests over a 48 hour period, they found that most of the male testers who attended this trial period were unable to stand not having their genitals and gave up. So it was from the Beta testing phase that the genital parts were implemented out of a sense of necessity. It seems that this was also part of the reason why SAO players were not allowed to change their characters' genders.

However, even if you had your genital parts, the question that I had prior to the official start of the game (meaning, before the incident) was whether or not there would be anxiety over the lack of proper function. I myself had agonized repeatedly on multiple occasions over the inability to release my pent up energy, but now I saw that if the ethics code or whatever was disabled, then functionality, probably even ejaculation was possible.

  • Please remember to gives sources! There isn't anything here to support your post as an answer. – FatalSleep Feb 6 '15 at 16:20
  • As I can remember, the statement of Kayaba are on the last ep of aincrad, but i cannot remember properly. The Asuna's statement are from the light novel, special ep, but I'll try to find the exact sources and edit the post. – Sakura Kinomoto Feb 6 '15 at 17:20
  • I've added some sources from light novel, but, i cannot place spoiler tag. Please someone can edit it? Thanks. – Sakura Kinomoto Feb 10 '15 at 9:22
  • Please check whether my edit doesn't change the meaning of your post. And I couldn't understand what you mean by Or, at least, you cannot change at first phase. - what first phase are you referring to? – nhahtdh Feb 10 '15 at 15:03
  • Probably these paragraph are incorrect. I'm talking about you cannot change this "at first instance". – Sakura Kinomoto Feb 10 '15 at 15:24

protected by nhahtdh Apr 18 '15 at 6:35

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.