3

In Fate/Zero, we see that the Matou don't really have a proper candidate to participate in the war. So Zouken adopted Sakura. Then Kariya comes up and participates. In exchange for winning the grail, Zouken will release Sakura from her fate as a mage (?).

Then Kariya loses. Therefore Zouken still needs Sakura, does he not? Zouken will continue training her to participate in the next war.

But, in Fate Stay/Night and UBW, this is the situation:

  • Sakura is a normal girl with no apparent knowledge of magic.
  • Shinji Matou is the master fighting for the Matou family.

Then, my question is:

  • Where was Shinji Matou during Fate/Zero? Why did Zouken need Sakura if he had Shinji?
2

Where was Shinji Matou during Fate/Zero?

Shinji was overseas at the time. He is only mentioned by his father Byakuya in the original Novel.

He was briefly mentioned by Byakuya in the original Fate/Zero novel, his only child was sent overseas in the name of studying.

Source: Shinji Matou - Other Appearances

Why did Zouken need Sakura if he had Shinji?

The original reason Zouken adopted Sakura was because Shinji was inferior as a magus due to their declining bloodline and wasn't fit to be an heir. Shinji stated in the Fate Route that this was because the Matou didn't properly adopt to the land, as they were foreigners to Japan, unlike the Tohsaka.

Furthermore, since having two heirs would weaken the inheritance (magic) that is to be passed down, and raising both as magi is always believed to cause conflict between the siblings down the track (as was the case with the Aozaki family), the Tohsaka's, like any other magus family, can only choose one heir.

Because the Tohsaka's and Matou's were ancient allies back from when the 3 families were tutored by Kischur Zelretch Schweinorg, Tokiomi Tohsaka put Sakura up for adoption to the Matou.

Like most magi, her father chose only one daughter to carry on his family's tradition as he believed raising an additional child would introduce competition. Zouken Matou, an ancient ally of the Tohsaka House, offered to adopt Sakura with the intention of training her as the successor of the Matou's magecraft as his own heir, Shinji, was incapable of sorcery.

Source: Sakura Matou - Background

The reason why Rin was chosen over Sakura was because Rin's Elemental Affinity was all five, while Sakura's was Imaginary Numbers. However, it was during her "training" which forcefully changed her Elemental Affinity to Water (Matou standard) that Zouken saw her potential as a Master.

As for Shinji Matou being a Master, he was a fake Master. From the beginning, Sakura was the Matou's Master. The book Shinji is shown to hold when he commanded Rider was the Book of the False Attendant, which was created from one of Sakura's Command Spells. Because the book cut Rider's Prana supply from Sakura but didn't change the source to Shinji, Rider needed other ways to gain Parana to stay manifested, thus the set up for Blood Fort Andromeda. Sakura made the book for Shinji to use, as she did not want to fight in the War because

  1. She could hurt Shirou (at that time, she was not aware that he had become a Master)
  2. She would hurt Rin (despite being told by Zouken to think of her former family as dead, she still recognized Rin as her sister)

Sakura was only forced to fight in the war in the Heaven's Feel Route when Shinji splashed something on Sakura during the Blood Fort's activation, causing the worms inside Sakura to go crazy. This forced her to fight in the war and put an end to it, lest she be consumed by the worms.

  • Sakura was aware of Shinji's magic barrier trap thing in school? Why did she stay inside (and became a victim) knowing this? Did she even try to save Shirou? (I remember she insisted Shirou to visit the dojo, but I think the dojo is within school grounds anyway so...) – Omega Apr 14 '15 at 22:32
  • @Omega i'm not sure, i don't remember Sakura being in the school during the Blood Fort's Activation (but i'm reaching that part in the Visual Novel) but remember that Magi like Rin can resists for a small amount of time. even then i would assume Shinji would have threatened Sakura not to interfere with the same threat he uses in Heaven's Feels when he is about to rape her, threatening to reveal the years of abuse to Shirou and claiming that Shirou would be disgusted with Sakura and no longer associate with her – Memor-X Apr 14 '15 at 22:46
  • (cont.) though the way he says it makes it sound like she wanted it and it's the fear of loosing Shirou that makes her complacent (though this has the opposite effect in Heaven's Feel). also as senshin mentioned in his comments, Shinji hates Sakura because he thought he was to be the heir and him raping her over the years was because Sakura took pity on him but he mistook it as her submitting to him. Shinji still believes he is to become the heir but even if he had won the war Sakura was going to be the heir – Memor-X Apr 14 '15 at 22:55
1

Where was Shinji Matou during Fate/Zero?

Well, he was five years old at the time. I guess that during Fate/Zero, he was hanging around the Matou residence or something.

Why did Zouken need Sakura if he had Shinji?

Heaven's Feel spoilers (I think?):

Shinji is a non-mage, like his father (Byakuya), and thus essentially useless to Zouken. This, again, was the whole point behind having Sakura adopted in from the Tohsaka family - Kariya was unwilling to cooperate, and Byakuya was a non-mage (and so would all his offspring be).

But, you say, Shinji is a Master in the fifth war! How can that be? Well, it turns out that Rider's actual master is Sakura. Basically, Shinji torments Sakura until she surrenders provisional control of Rider to Shinji by means of a magical book that behaves like a Command Spell.

So anyway, Shinji, like Kariya, did not really factor into Zouken's plans. With both of them, it would have been nice if they won the war, but Zouken's ultimate plans revolved around Sakura. During Fate/Zero, his plan was for Sakura's offspring to win the fifth war; but when the fifth war came around fifty-ish years early, his goal was to have Sakura herself win the war on his behalf. This obviously doesn't work out well for Zouken in Fate or UBW, but he comes pretty close to getting what he wants in Heaven's Feel.

This whole confusion you're having is one of the big reasons why watching Fate/Zero before Heaven's Feel makes for a somewhat subpar experience - knowing in advance that Zouken has all these sinister plans, you can't help but wonder what he's been up to in the first two routes and what the whole deal with Sakura and Shinji is and so forth.

  • Sakura is/was Rider's master in Stay/Night and UBW? So she is indeed a trained mage the whole time and knows about the war etc? In that case, why did Zouken approve of Shinji taking her Master status? Surely she is at least more useful than Shinji, having been trained with the insects. – Omega Apr 14 '15 at 21:40
  • @Omega. It's safer that way. If the enemy knows Sakura is the master, they can target her. As long as they believe Sakura is a normal girl and Shinji's the actual master, they'll try to kill him and reveal themselves in the process. This would allow Sakura to deal with them while they believe they've won and still don't know who she is. – Nolonar Apr 14 '15 at 22:04
  • @Nolonar that makes sense. But when Shinji triggered the mana-absorbing barrier trap thing in the school, why was Sakura a victim as well? Supposedly the barrier was Zouken's idea, so surely Zouken would not want Sakura to get trapped or even hurt in it (since she's the real master). Did Shinji just do it on purpose? He could've told her not to come to school or something. – Omega Apr 14 '15 at 22:23
  • @Omega. I'm not too sure myself. From what I've seen, I think Shinji is jealous of Sakura. He might've simply not cared about her at all. – Nolonar Apr 14 '15 at 22:33
  • @Omega "why did Zouken approve of Shinji taking her Master status?" - I don't remember the details, but I believe Zouken had some sort of Batman gambit going, wherein Shinji's participation in the war would somehow lead to a better outcome for him. Of course, Rider's early death in Fate and UBW (to Saber and Kuzuki, respectively) must have put a wrench in those plans. – senshin Apr 14 '15 at 22:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.