6

I don't play Fate/Stay Night visual novel, but I'm quite a fan of the anime series, mainly because of its historic sense — with those people from the legends and all. However, I've spotted a flaw — albeit not a fatal one — and it bothers me a bit.

In the universe of Fate/Stay Night, Saber is the legendary King Arthur (or rather, Arthuria) Pendragon that comes from Celtic legends. With such a background, I expect her to use a Western fencing style (though the term is not exclusively used in the Western world the way that word means today).

While Arthuria did, in fact, fight with the Western fencing style throughout the anime in all her real battles, I've noticed that, especially in her training with Shiro, she used an Eastern fencing style.

Was it ever explained in the visual novel if she learned the Eastern fencing style before or anything? The age in which she lived in was all but related to the easternmost part of the world.

  • It is unclear exactly what you are asking, are you asking about her particular sword fighting style? – SWard Jul 30 '15 at 15:02
  • 4
    I think its pretty clear, its just the formatting and the question was put at the end, but not even the very last sentence. I would put your question, which I'm assuming is: "I just want to know if it was explained in the game (novel), like, if she got to learn it before or anything" where "it" would be kenjutsu. – ton.yeung Jul 30 '15 at 15:25
  • If you're talking about the DEEN anime, I remember it being pretty ambiguous what style she was actually using when she trained with Shirou, as their training mostly consisted of Saber easily dodging his blows and beating the snot out of him, which doesn't require any particular style, just general combat skill (which Saber has in abundance). Of course they were fighting with kendo shinai, and a seasoned warrior like Saber would probably naturally grip such a long hilt with two hands, but I don't remember the actual techniques looking particularly Eastern. – Torisuda Jul 30 '15 at 21:19
6

In the Fate/SN world, heroes learn everything they need to know about about age they were summoned in. Knowledge such as how to operate common machinery, customs, and language are automatically learned during their summoning. As an example, Saber learned how to ride motorcycles in Fate/Zero. Motorcycles did not exist in her age, but she knows how to operate one nevertheless. This is also the reason why there is no language barrier between Saber and Shirou.

As Kendo is a common sport in Japan and a martial art involving swords, Saber could have learned this particular Eastern fencing style as part of the Japanese customs she had to learn from her summoning.

  • 3
    Riding a motorcycle was a consequence of her Ride skill. When traveling to Japan in Fate/Zero she remarks that, while she was given knowledge of what a plane is (and so is not spooked by it as a magical flying demon machine or whatever), she doesn't know how they work. But nevertheless she could fly it without problem if need be due to her Ride skill. The motorcycle was similar: she knew of motorcycles, but her ability to ride them, masterfully in particular, was one of her Servant skills rather than knowledge just given to any Servant. – zibadawa timmy Jul 30 '15 at 19:32
2

I'm going to expand my comment on Frosteeze's answer into my own answer.

Servants have special skills and abilities by virtue of their class. These are granted to them by the grail system, and may give them abilities and skills they did not and could not have possessed in their actual lives/legends. In-universe this is to help bridge the (vast) cultural and linguistic gaps between summoner and Servant, and to make sure a Servant's capacities aren't ruined because they're scared of the demonic picture box, or can't conduct themselves in society even in the simplest of ways. Out of universe, this was probably just to make the writing easier and the characters more relatable to the reader.

On the flip side, the class can also restrict the servant: Cu Chulainn would have had greater use of his rune magic as a Caster class, Hercules would have had access to several of his NPs in any class other than Berserker (and would have probably been more powerful as an Archer), etc. To go on a tangent into the more complicated interactions, Saber's legend includes a mythical spear, so you might expect her to be able to be summoned as Lancer, but due to the overwhelming association of her to Excalibur (both in her own mind and in legends), she can only ever be summoned as Saber.

In Fate/Zero we see several instances of this from Saber.

The first is when she is boarding a plane to Japan with Irisviel. She explains to Iri that she is aware of what a plane is and is not alarmed by it. The grail provides her with this information to give her the fundamentals of the time and area of the war she is summoned for. This is also why she and every other Servant speaks fluent Japanese, incidentally. Or why Rider has no issues with reading Japanese texts, despite it being questionable at best if she would have even been literate in any language in her myth. But more importantly is what she says immediately after that. While she knows what a plane is, she has no idea exactly how it works or even how one would fly it. Nevertheless, she knows that as soon as she sits in the pilot seat she would would have zero problems flying it expertly. This is due to her Ride skill: it lets her "ride" or "pilot" anything up to a certain degree of mystery, and her rank B in particular easily includes non-magical transports such as planes and motorcycles. She also expertly rides a super-charged performance motorcycle later on in Fate/Zero.

The Saber class also has intrinsic sword skills, and they will work in the same way: the grail will provide them knowledge of how to use their "sword" up to the proficiency level dictated by their skill. In the vast majority of cases (except, say, Zero Lancelot), a servant would only ever use their Noble Phantasms or other weapons that came with them at the summoning. As such, while Saber probably was not provided with intrinsic knowledge of actual kendo combat--though as part of the generic cultural information she probably knew what it was in basic terms, what a shinai looked like, etc.--, she was granted expert level proficiency with the style from simply holding a shinai.

Fake Assassin (and even True Assassin) also has weapon skills, and in Fake Assassin's case they exceed Saber's. You might note how well Fake Assassin handles Saber, despite her fighting in a foreign style with an obfuscated weapon. And similarly for how Saber handles a foreign opponent with what should be an unfamiliar style. This is probably part of the standard trope of legendary fighters being able to read their opponents and know their fighting style after just a few exchanges, and would be encapsulated by the weapon skill involved.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.