4

This question is inspired by the following rule of the Death Note (source: deathnote.wikia.com):

If a Death Note owner accidentally misspells a name four times, that person will be free from being killed by the Death Note. However, if they intentionally misspell the name four times, the Death Note owner will die.

  • Does writing an alias, when you assume it is the real name, count as accidentally misspelling a name or intentionally misspelling the name?
  • Does it matter if the alias is similiar to the real name?
  • What happens if the alias is similiar to the real name and as a result of a misspell you actually write the real name? Will the victim die?
  • I think this is one of the questions where "we don't know" is the only reasonable answer. We've never seen a case where this happens. – kaine Nov 24 '15 at 19:41
  • 2
    @kaine Does that mean that it is a bad question? Should I remove it? I've only seen the anime so far, maybe things are hidden in the manga. I've seen a lot of similiar questions with good answers. – wythagoras Nov 24 '15 at 19:43
  • 4
    NO, the fact we don't know the answer does not make it a bad question. Unfortunately, it just might mean that we can't give you a useful answer. There, also, could easily be a detail or mangaka comment I am unfamiliar with. I can write what I know though. – kaine Nov 24 '15 at 19:49
4

In order for a person to be killed by the Death Note there are only 3 relevant requirements:

  • They have to be alive...obviously...
  • You have to write their true name.
  • You have to picture the person as you write it.

Every person has a true name which can be seen with Shinigami eyes. That name does not change. There are several details we don't know about how that works but a nickname will never appear there.

You have two questions:

  • Are repeated writings of an alias considered by the Death Note to be intentional misspellings, unintentional misspellings, or just invalid input?
  • What happens if I accidentally write the correct name thinking it is an alias?

If you write the correct name (spelled correctly) while picturing that living person, that person will die. You do not need to know what you are doing as you do it. So in the case of you last question, the answer is: "Yes, the victim will die."

We don't, however, have enough information to answer the first question. When Light was writing the name of the victim from the first episode he kills in the street, he writes at least 8 different spellings of his name. He knows only one of those could be correct. As the name is among the first 4 (third I think), the victim dies. Light does not die for writing the final 4 nor does the victim retroactively become immune. This is the only time we see so many misspellings of a person's name. The last 4 either seems to be considered invalid input (as he is already about to die) or misspellings that don't make him immune as he is already doomed.

We can speculate that if the person thinks he knows a person's real name, he cannot be intentionally misspelling the name to make that person immortal. Therefore, the owner will likely not die from this course of events. This, however, is just speculation with a limited amount of evidence.

What we do not know at all is whether the Death Note will consider the correctly spelled alias to be a misspelling of a person's given name at all. A correctly spelled alias is technically not a misspelling so might not count. If the name is very different, it is possible it might not be recognized as belonging to that person so that person is not impacted at all. This is the key point to the question and at no point in the anime or in the part of manga I've read has there been anything to clarify this further. I personally would go as far as to say the Shinigami probably don't know the specific answer to this question.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.