6

Index episode 14 around 14:00 minutes.

Touma awakens to find his right hand on Misaka 10032's chest. 10032 then states that she placed his hand there herself, and that she was reading electrical currents to measure his life signs.

Given that Imagine Breaker is a passive power, how could that be possible?

So, is it

  1. A white lie. She wasn't reading him. Not likely because Misaka clones usually don't lie and show little emotion.
  2. A plot hole. They just forgot what power was in the hand.
  3. An animation faux. She was actually holding his left hand in the Light Novel.
  • maybe she's not using a method that Imagine Breaker would cancel out, something that's just generic technology since it's not like appliances and that shut down if Touma uses his right hand right? – Memor-X Dec 11 '16 at 12:41
  • @Memor-X whille it is true Imagine Breaker only works on the supernatural, there is no device in her hands, and she mentions measuring brainwaves.... – Mindwin Dec 11 '16 at 13:53
  • It has been shown that Touma was always awake when he uses Imagine Breaker. Maybe it just won't activate if he is unconscious? – 絢瀬絵里 Dec 11 '16 at 14:26
  • @AyaseEri during the arc in Italy, the Amakusa church uses Toumas hand to destroy magical clothes while he was unconscious – looper Feb 9 '17 at 14:02
  • Interesting question. I verified that it was his right arm in the manga, but I'd like to see what the light novels say. Could it be because her power is reading electrical current internally (inside his arm), and not coming in contact with Imagine Breaker? There were also some cases where Imagine Breaker wasn't very effective because the power regenerated too quickly (A certain Level 6 esper comes to mind). So it could be that since Touma is in direct contact with Misaka 10032's body, Imagine Breaker can't negate her abilities quickly enough to stop her from using them. – Shaymin Gratitude Feb 9 '17 at 16:33
4

This isn't much of an answer, but as the question does specifically ask about whether there is a difference between the light novels and the other versions, here are my findings:

In Yen Press's English translation of A Certain Magical Index: Volume 3, which hand of Touma's that Misaka 10032 is holding to her chest is unspecified. Here's the quote:

Lastly, he noticed Little Misaka's hands embracing one of his.
It didn't really matter, but she was holding both of her hands to her chest...

Furthermore, it also isn't specified which side of the bed Misaka 10032 is sitting on:

After all, the only person in the room was Little Misaka, quietly sitting on a chair at the side of the bed-

Misaka 10032's explanation for why she was holding Touma's hand to her chest are same in the manga and light novel: she says she's measuring his brain waves and pulse via bioelectricity. Neither offers any more insight than that.

From this, one might find it reasonable to conclude that it was indeed an error introduced by the anime and that by the ambiguity in the light novels, we should conclude it was Touma's left hand because it would be impossible for Misaka 10032 to read his bioelectricity from his right.

  • Have my gratitude, my vote and the green checkmark. – Mindwin May 5 '17 at 11:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.