9

While watching episode 29, we saw that Ymir could read the letters on the can, but Reiner could not. Why?

Manga spoiler:

As far as I remember, both Ymir and Reiner are Eldians. So should they not both be able to read the letters on the can? What language is supposed to be on it? Why can Ymir read it, but Reiner could not?

6

After some researches on the wiki, i found something interesting :

Even if they both are Eldians, Ymir was part of the cult of Ymir (It's also the reason why she was condamned to be changed into a titan). It could be there she learned the language on the can, and this language is probably linked to Ymir Fritz herself. However it is pure speculation since we have no way to really know.

Source : Chapter 89 (p. 8-13), Eren is reading Ymir's letter which tells us about her past.

3

The previous answer is a good one, but I have another hypothesis.

Reiner does indeed know the language, but pretends not to, in order to keep his identity safe. He acted in shock because he realized who Ymir was (the titan who ate his friend).

In the anime Reiner does not say "I don't know the language". This is only mentioned in the manga chapter 38.

2

There is an official answer to this question.


This post contains spoilers. Make sure to be caught up with the manga (currently Chapter 110).


First, let us lay the groundwork for the answer:

Eldian is the official language of Eldia, Marley, and many other nations around the world.

As a result of the old Eldian Empire's imperialism, Eldian is a known language throughout the world. It is spoken both inside and outside the Walls, although their writing systems differ. Ambassadors from across the globe used it to communicate with Willy Tybur during his pre-party.


There are three known writing systems for Eldian:


Ancient Eldia

An archaic version of Eldian is found in ancient manuscripts and texts that were sent by Eren Kruger to the Eldia Restorationists. The language appears to include a lot of visuals and was used by the Eldians from a long time ago. Although it was unreadable to the Grisha Yeager and Restorationists, he and his fellow patriots assumed that the texts confirm their beliefs that Ymir Fritz had brought wealth to mankind, and that the Subjects of Ymir are the chosen children of God.


Inside the Walls

This system of writing is found only inside the Walls. The writing is composed by short, straight strokes and sharp corners, and written horizontally.


Outside the Walls

Another system of writing is found when the Survey Corps settled in Utgard Castle after searching for a supposed breach in Wall Rose. They found supplies that were left behind by unknown occupants, but the labels found on them were unreadable to most of the soldiers. When Ymir went off to find food, she found a can with a herring label on it which she proceeded to read out loud. She gave the can to Reiner Braun, who was shocked to find out that she could read the writing. It is later revealed that both Reiner Braun and Ymir came from Marley, confirming that the writing is the system used by the Marleyans and the Eldians living outside the Walls.

Now regarding your question: According to the Attack on Titan Guidebook,

Reiner Braun could read the herring can like Ymir, but he lied in order to protect his own identity while forcing Ymir to reveal hers.

1

Well, I can't answer your question directly but you also have to consider that Ymir has been wandering as a titan for about 60 years, thus making her a lot more "older" than Reiner or Berthold. Then again, it is highly unlikely that a language can change so drastically over the course of 60 years…

In this regard I'd like to refer to Chapter 47 of the manga:

  • This premise might actually be the answer. Ymir was born 60 years earlier than reiner, so it might be an 'older' language as a lot has happened in their home town in those years... I should reread with that in mind. Thanks. – Peter Raeves May 31 '17 at 12:49
  • Glad I could help! – Ryota Jun 2 '17 at 22:49
0

All of the other answers are wrong.

SPOILER ALERT

Reiner deals with a dissociate personality disorder. This is because he had developed his persona of a Eldian soldier while actually being a Marleyan enemy, to ease his sense of guilt and overall trauma of causing thousands of deaths. This soldier persona is unaware of Reiner's true identity of being an enemy from another nation (the language is in Marleyan), so this fabricated, soldier part of Reiner's self-consciousness couldn't recognize the language.

  • Can you provide sources to support your claim? As it stands, this is just purely speculation with no basis from manga or anime information. I am updated on both manga and anime and I can't see how this is even possible at all. – W. Are Mar 11 at 13:52

protected by Community Mar 11 at 7:46

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.