3

What did Shouko sign to Shouya in Koe No Katachi volume 7, chapter 54?

Note: the below images are the signs that she used, in the order that they appear (right to left).

Eight images of Shouko signing a specific message, from right to left.

  • my bad, i would more careful from now on... – Gagantous Sep 17 '17 at 0:22
  • @Makoto As far as I understand it, whether the content is originally taken from a licensed source has basically nothing to do with whether fair use can be claimed. Even images from works that are freely available elsewhere can't automatically be used here. The important factors (in the context of this site) are how much of the work is reproduced here and what purpose it is serving on this site. – Logan M Sep 17 '17 at 1:42
  • 1
    @LoganM: Yes, that's a fair point. I'll delete my comment, revert the edit and we can carry on from there. – Makoto Sep 17 '17 at 2:49
  • 1
    I have koe no katachi physical edition ( all the 7 volume ) , but it's indonesian translation. And I don't know if i have to take a picture of the page that I wanted to mention it And I don't have any acces to digital licensed English site like chrunchyol and such as, and thats the reason why I used image from pirate d site. Sorry, and thanks for the image @Makoto – Gagantous Sep 17 '17 at 5:49
  • In the anime version Shouko talks about the accident happened because she couldn't change, so she thought it would be better if she was gone and asks for forgiveness. (Won't post it as an answer, as there might be differences between the manga and the anime) – Gorzius Sep 21 '17 at 18:03
2

So I watched the limited theatrical release today. While I can't say that I recall anything verbatim, I'll be updating my answer from here.

Shouko says, not signs, in the movie, that

She believed that if she weren't around anymore, everything would be better, which is what led her to attempt suicide in the first place.

This tears into the heart of the matter: the immense guilt and discomfort that Shouko feels about the entire situation, which is what led her to make that decision.

Also, this highlights a point in which the film diverges from the manga, so take this with a grain of salt.


While I can't interpret JSL very well, we can infer what happened through the use of context clues a few chapters earlier.

This happened after Shoya effectively saved Shouko's life, when she attempted to jump off her balcony into the river below. Recall in an earlier chapter, Shouko and Shoya swapped positions, effectively keeping her on the balcony, and him plummeting to the water below.

From that, what we can infer is...

Shouko thought that Shoya was dead, and was feeling incredibly remorseful for attempting suicide, and that Shoya had been badly injured due to her actions. She's frantically apologizing and is grateful that he's alive.

  • I'd encourage one to read through the context of the manga several times, too. In this example, since I reread it, there's little missing from context or from interpretation. – Makoto Sep 16 '17 at 23:09
1

I found a good sources to answer this question These are from the chapter 54, page 9,10,and 11.

Page 9, third panel.

You - Fall Down

"You Fell down"

Page 9, fourth panel.

Me - Bad

"My Fault"

Page 10, first panel.

Same

"(At that time) same"

Page 10, second panel. ( Not sure about this one )

Minimum

"I think that it is the lowest"

Page 10, fourth panel ( Not sure about this one too )

Relationship

"I messed up my relationship with everyone"

Page 10, fifth panel ( and this one too )

Past - Same

"At that time (when I was in elementary school) and I have not changed"

Page 10, seventh and eight panel ( and this one too )

Important

"Everyone is Important ... "Based on(?)"

References(Japanese's site) : los-endos.hatenablog.com(Japanese)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.