7

So far, two episodes are out, and the following observations about Violet Evergarden are made:

  1. She wants to learn what "I love you" means, a common trope among AI and other robotic characters.
  2. She used to have human arms, but lost them during the Four-Year War.
  3. In episode 2 when she was having dinner, we only saw her cut the fish awkwardly, but not eat or drink even once.
  4. She's used to work long hours and her choice of word for eating and sleeping, "recharge", is not intended for humans.

So what is she, exactly?

10

She is human. This can be further proven by the fact that:

  1. She can bleed. As seen during the flashbacks of the war from several episodes, namely one and two. If it was oil, it would've been black; which it wasn't.

  2. She has emotions. She was worried about Major Gilbert and was curious about the meaning of the phrase, 'I love you' and how it made her feel.

She only looks like a robot because of her mechanical arms. She lost her human arms during the war. She is only awkward, because she never understood how to interact with other individuals in a normal society. She only knows how to act like a soldier.

3

She is indeed a human, but her awkward social skills are due to her being in the army from her very childhood (since she was 10 y/o). She lived as a soldier and never really got to experience the world as a normal girl.

1

Violet is a human girl. In the first episode of season one, she starts in the hospital. If she was a robot she would most likely just be rebuilt.

0

Violet is human, it isn't obvious at the start, but as her emotions are explored later on, it becomes even more prominent. I think the makers intended for viewers to be confused at the start because of her mechanical arms as well as emotionless attitude. This was because she lived all her life either on the streets or in the army. Also as seen from the flashbacks she can indeed bleed like humans.

  • Can you provide any sources? – kuwaly Apr 17 '18 at 22:59
0

I think they are leaving it purposely ambiguous. But I don’t think she’s human, not fully. You never see her eat, and only drink tea. When she lost her arms in battle, she did not act AT ALL like a young girl who got horribly maimed. If she were human, she would have bled out. There has to be a reason Captain Bouganville treats her so poorly and adamantly refers to her as a tool. And a reason she can regularly best trained soldiers. I think she might be a cyborg akin to the T-800, with an organic shell.

0

Violet Evergarden is indeed a human, just because shes socially awkward and doesn't eat doesn't mean anything. Violet was in the army at such a young age and was only taught how to act like a soldier, She must've went through a hard time because she lost her arms. Also she was bleeding in a couple of the other scenes so she has to be a human, If she was a cyborg, robot she would defiantly have black oil coming out of her but that didn't happen.

0

Violet is human, however, she doesn’t really know how to act around people nor socialize properly due to being raised in the military.

protected by Community Jan 28 at 10:55

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.