8

Besides the out of universe reason that his identity was hidden as a plot device, is there any in universe reason people don't know Naruto is the 4th Hokage's son?

After all, Minato was married to Uzumaki Kushina. She must have been pregnant for a while before her and Minato's death. Being the wife of the 4th Hokage, she must have been, at least to some degree, a celebrity figure. Everybody would have known she was pregnant. She must have been sporting a good baby bump for at least a couple months before her death. Shortly after the time of her death, there's suddenly a newborn baby named Uzumaki Naruto wandering around (that happens to have a striking resemblance to the 4th, which becomes more and more obvious as he ages), and nobody made the connection they were related?

Suddenly orphaned, Naruto was left to grow up knowing nothing of his parents, receiving only his mother's last name because the Third Hokage thought that it was best that nobody knew that he was related to the Fourth Hokage.

I know that the Third hid his relation to the 4th, but simply using the 4th's wife's last name doesn't seem like it would be very effective. Was that really all it took to fool just about EVERYBODY? Is there some other explaination to Naruto's anonymity?

  • 2
    Speculation, Nine tailed fox invasion was a full scale war and Naruto likely was not the only orphan (Iruka). People expect what they want to see. A son of Hokage is like a celebrity (Konahamaru - Honorable Grandson) and treated well in the village. People would assume everyone died together, 4th Hokage, Kushina and 3rd's Wife as well. While Naruto would be hidden among other orphans probably a son of a refugee (Uzumaki village is no more). What I'm saying is its like Superman's Glasses, people have pre conceived notions and they confirm what they see not question its logic. – Arcane Jul 17 '18 at 19:28
  • @Arcane I suggest you post your comment as an answer. While it is speculation, it is speculation based on fact (that there were likely hundreds of orphans and Naruto would have just been one of the hundreds), and that could have been sufficient to hide his identity. Although, in my opinion, it doesn't completely explain it, since there were so few Uzumaki left, and as far as I'm aware, Kushina was the only one in Konoha at the time of the 9 Tails attack. – Jun Kang Jul 18 '18 at 19:12
  • @JunKang Elaborated the points I felt were necessary. Addressing your concer Kushina was the only Uzumaki like Minato was the only Namikaze. She may be the only one living in the Village but she came from "somewhere". The more likely explanantion is that Uzumaki homeland was destroyed, there were still some Uzumaki in land of Fire probably nomadic. 3rd contacted them for someone with Uzumaki blood to be heir to the Jichuriki. This only makes sense rather than a random girl being found at the right moment – Arcane Jul 19 '18 at 18:17
  • @Arcane I think your answer is probably the best I'll get to explain Naruto's anonymity. My only issue, in my opinion your answer doesn't explain, is the fact that Kushina is the only Uzumaki in Konoha. You said likely there were still some Uzumaki in the land of Fire probably nomadic, but I don't think that's accurate. There are only scattered survivors and Kushina was selected to be the new jinchūriki and came to the village BEFORE the Uzumaki clan was destroyed. While I'm not saying there CAN'T be other Uzumaki clan members wandering around, there is no evidence for that. – Jun Kang Jul 19 '18 at 19:46
  • 1
    The plot addresses and accomodates as much characters as its needed. What was important to the storyline was the end result not how it happened. But yeah, maybe someone will ask the author. I feel we don't see any Namikaze clan members for the same reason. There was no need for the plot. – Arcane Jul 21 '18 at 17:49
5

While I don't like posting speculative answers, upon plenty of time and thought I think this is the best I can think of. Expanding on my comment on the question, I'll try to logically conclude why many didn't relate the boy Naruto with the son of Hokage.

  1. We see the scale of invasion pretty early in the episode and see it was a sudden war worse than the attack by the Sand/Sound villages. The strategy of saving the villagers probably resulted from the Nine-Tailed Fox Attack. The knowledge of Jinchuriki is SECRET information and wasn't revealed to anyone but the Hokage and top-tier Anbu. Hence, while plenty of people had seen Kushina pregnant, no one knew the significance of the birth (even Minato didn't know). The sudden death of the Fourth and his wife naturally led people to conclude the worst. We also know that some Anbu and the Third's wife died as well. When so many people die together, how can they assume a new born baby survive?
  2. We know of at least two orphans from the Nine-Tailed attack. Iruka and Naruto. (I believe Kurenai's parents died too, but not sure if it was filler). When the Third Hokage retook the position, the village was turmoil, and plenty of rehab efforts were made, including for orphan children whose parents had died. Uzumaki Village is extinct, but there may have been several wandering clans in the Land of Fire (not the village), who may have visited the village. And Naruto may've been thought to be the son of guests who unfortunately died in the attack. The nature of the Third's kindness is well known and no one would question his interest in the kid of a guest of the village who died because of the failure.
  3. The Hokage's family are treated as special in village. Tsunade (the First's granddaughter), Asuma (ran away from home to escape the shadow of Hokage's son), Konohamaru (Honorable Grandson + Special Tutor) and even Boruto (Konohamaru would naturally take him in). Everyone likes them. Treats them with respect. In Naruto's case only the shadow of fear lingered, and it didn't change. If he were "special" why didn't anybody intervene? This created the vicious circle of some people staying away because of the fear that being the Fourth's son makes him a target (Kakashi), some jounin let him be (Shikaku), some actively shunned him. This shunning gradually increased and seeped into the kids as well. No one expects a village oddball to be that of Hokage heritage.
  4. The most important point is hiding in plain sight. Naruto isn't the first nor the last to use this technique for hiding the true nature of main character. Superman is a prime example. People don't expect "special" people to live among the common! What they don't expect they just don't see it. This is true in real life as well.
-1

It was clearly stated by minato that if Naruto is known as his son, he posses a great threat from the shinobi world. That's why third protects Naruto and doesn't let the village or anyone else to know about Naruto's birth parents

  • This doesn't answer the question. I didn't ask why Naruto's relation to the 4th is kept secret. I asked why nobody knew they were related, or could guess they were related, given the fact that the only thing done to keep it secret was giving Naruto his mother's last name. Was that really all it took to fool just about EVERYBODY? Is there some other explaination to Naruto's anonymity? – Jun Kang Jul 18 '18 at 19:08
-1

It's because Minato stated when Naruto met him first, that if anyone knew that Naruto was his son, then he'd be in danger.

enter image description here

  • 1
    Please include the chapter number too. – Ero Sɘnnin May 25 at 14:55
  • This doesn't answer the question. – Jun Kang May 29 at 15:34
-3

In my opinion that is something that the author can't explain at all. Because: It is suppose that the knowledge about the jinchuriki and about who the jinchuriki is, is a state secret. But we all know about the loneliness and discrimination that Naruto had to live, just because all the people in village knew he was the cell of the nine tailed fox. So that is something which in my opinion doesn't match and is unexplainable.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.