0

I see that in many Animes, there are cross-dressing (or maybe trans) characters, like Hideri Kanzaki of Blend-S, and they usually have awfully high-pitched voices. These characters in anime and manga fall into a trope and are usually referred to as "trap characters."

Why do these characters even have high-pitched voices?

I can't think of any character that falls into this trope and has their voice fall into a lower, typically male, voice register.

  • 1
    You should not be updating your question to a completely new one. You should not be changing your questions completely even if it is tangentially related, regardless of whether there was any answers or not. Post their new question as a separate post if you have another question. Make sure it's on-topic. Music theory related questions especially related to voice tones not on-topic. – кяαzєя 2 days ago
  • @кяαzєя so THAT'S why it was downvoted, right? – Yubin-chan 2 days ago
  • 1
    I don't know, but it was probably due to the poor quality of your original question. – кяαzєя 2 days ago
  • 1
    I can't think of any character that falls into this trope and has their voice fall into a lower, typically male, voice register. If you want an exception, here you go: Kirito in Sword Art Online season 2 – user6391 yesterday
11

The whole point of the "trap" archetype is to trick people (both the audience watching the show, and the characters in the show itself) into thinking the character is female when they aren't. If they were to speak with a masculine voice, the illusion would be ruined the moment they opened their mouth, which kind of ruins the point.

Aside from this, it would also be very jarring to hear a masculine voice coming from someone who does not look very masculine. The reverse is also true: it would be extremely jarring to see a muscular male speaking in a high-pitched soprano voice.

Screwball comedies like Pop Team Epic may use ill-fitting voices for intentional comedic effect (see also: Up), but with "traps", the comedy instead comes from people mistaking them for the opposite gender. Giving them a masculine voice would, as I've already noted, ruin that particular gag, and then there's not much point making them a "trap" in the first place.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.