First of all, Eren was a titan shifter, so he cant go abnormal after being shifter (i believe).
Second of all, we dont know exactly if the power injection Eren uses are turning people into titans.
And third, Rod Reiss mentioned he cannot enherit Founding titan, that's why he was forcing Historia into doing it - we can assume he knew he will become abnormal after injection.
So there's something special about reiss that makes him abnormal, diferent from other people like Eren or Historia.
But how did he know that? Why he became abnormal? We can't tell right now.
Well, there's a lot of mystery around Abnormal titans and it's not yet explained. We only know some titans are more intelligent or behave in different ways or are looking very different.
There's wiki article stating that titan shifters are abnormal too.
So its possible that abnormals cant become titan shifters (cant become "double abnormals").
So Rod knew somehow he will turn abnormal and won't be able to enherit titan power.