1

Is it possible for an author to just write a story and let someone else make a manga or anime of it?

I have no idea where to find the answers. I have searched and only came up with typing here. I cannot try anything because I do not know where you start.

4
  • 4
    You can be bad at drawing like author One from One Punch Man and still make a huge success webcomic which later someone is interested in making a manga and anime out of it pm1.narvii.com/6062/… – Pablo Jan 4 at 13:43
  • 4
    Plenty of mainstream anime / manga originate from Visual Novels and Light novels which are, in fact, written stories (and maybe some illustrations) – nabulator Jan 4 at 14:02
  • Pablo sorry but I'm even worse at drawing than that so drawing is no option for me. – Emily Nordien Jan 4 at 19:39
  • Are you already a published (text based) author or looking to self-publish? Does it have to be a manga/anime? Do you specifically want to target the Japanese market? Or do you just want your story turned into a graphic novel/comic book or animated movie/series in English or whatever language you normally write in? – Gwyn Jan 10 at 17:50
5

Sure, although it depends heavily on your talents, language, and most of all luck (or alternatively, massive amounts of money).

You basically have three paths:

  1. Get published as a Light Novel or Webnovel, and get a manga adaptation.
  2. Become a story writer for a manga.
  3. Commission someone to draw your story into a manga.

for all intents and purposes, to break into 1 or 2, you will need to write in Japanese (or to a lesser degree, Chinese or Korean) and post your work to a fiction posting site like 小説家になろう or pixiv. Ride the trend (currently it would be Isekai), promote your work on the likes of Japanese Twitter, and with a massive amount of luck (with the tosh that gets published these days, I am not sure talent is that necessary), you will rise above the massive sea of LN writer hopefuls to get selected for a publishing deal - and if you are even luckier and sell well, you might get a manga adaptation.

I am not going to say it is impossible to get a manga adaptation as an English writer, but Japanese publishers really have no reason to look for talent elsewhere when there are thousands of amateur writers committing millions of words in their own language online for free hoping for that big publishing break, even at bottom barrel rates.

Submitting your work to publishers directly rather than online is of course an option, but that seems to have been mostly phased out for the online model.

Lastly, for 3, if you have plenty of money and don't care about actually selling your work, you can just commission an artist or (amateur or freelance) mangaka to draw your story (although it will likely cost you an arm and leg for what is in essence a vanity project)

EDIT: this is a response to OP's comment that became far too long for its own good, so I am adding it here. Mods, please tell me if this isn't appropriate.

I will be frank; it is nearly impossible for an English writer to break into the Japanese manga market directly, regardless of talent.

The manga market is absolutely saturated with talented hopefuls (most of whom will never even get a oneshot published, let alone a series), and the LN market even more so. Thus like I have said, Japanese publishers have very little reason to turn to foreign talent - why risk the legal and communication pitfalls when there are hundreds of Japanese who are eager to replace them for little recompense?

I'd say that the best chance for a foreign writer to get published in Japan is to be either A. To get an internationally bestselling book or B. work with an artist (as @Mary has said) to get a bestselling comic, and have a Japanese publisher pick up rights for localization of your work.

For A., there are cases of foreign books getting a manga adaptation (e. g. The Unwomanly Face of War. Note that this book is by a Nobel Literature prize-winning author), but they are very rare, and generally reserved for the bestselling of books or classics in the public domain.

For B, while foreign comics (e.g. Chinese and Korean webtoons and Western comics) have recently made decent headway in penetrating into the Japanese market, most of them deviate signifcantly from the cliches and customs of the manga genre (and are successful at least partially thanks to that difference).

If you really want keep it limited to manga form, I suppose you could find a mangaka who is willing to collabrate with you via both translating and drawing your work, but that honestly isn't much more likely than getting a bestselling book.

TL;DR: It is really bloody difficult, especially if you can't write in Japanese.

3
  • what if I don't speak Japanese but a huge imagination that drives everyone around me crazy and also I like writing. – Emily Nordien Jan 5 at 14:02
  • 1
    A fourth path is finding a collaborator. – Mary Jan 6 at 4:33
  • If you really just want the "manga aesthetic" things are likely easier - there are plenty of western manga-style artists (although finding someone who is willing to collaborate with you is obviously a much harder problem). However, getting it out there is another matter - while I have heard of Western "manga" (notwithstanding the debatable usage of the term) getting published in the old Tokyopop days, I am not sure that is a thing anymore with the absolute deluge of licensed Japanese material that western manga publishers now have at their disposal. – mantra Jan 7 at 1:28
0

Yes. This could be the norm very shortly. I think it's rare for any one of us to have a distinctly unique idea. Not long ago I had a "unique idea" that there should be an ANIME-GAN (Generative Adversarial Network). This Anime-GAN would basically be able to

  • color manga and doujinshi automatically, or with structured text descriptions
  • anime minor scenes with either a starting frame only, or a few key frames, and a structured set of text instructions

While I've found nothing specifically like that, I have found something close that existed years ago.

  1. Make Girls Moe https://make.girls.moe/#/
  2. Paints Chainer https://github.com/pfnet/PaintsChainer

Both of these projects are from 2017. This is mostly before the popularization/wide-spread adoption of things like transformer neural networks. Given the pace of improvement in the area of neural networks, your idea could be feasible at the individual level fairly soon. Not unlike how anyone with video recording capability can publish and gain traction on YouTube, the same might follow for the Mange/Anime industry.

2
  • what if this is a unique idea that no one came up with yet that is a anime or manga title?? how do I get people to at least try to help me make it work – Emily Nordien Jan 5 at 14:06
  • I think like the @mantra mentioned, you would want to find someone to make sketches for what you write, in-line with the anime drawing genre. If you have an idea of what characters should look like you should write it down. As far as "self-publishing" in general, that term will being up a lot of results. quora.com/What-websites-allow-you-to-self-publish-your-manga – VISQL Jan 6 at 20:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.