3

All of todays Eldians have a common ancestor, Ymir. But in all Eldians there is also a royal bloodline, Fritz/Reiss. This royal blood line came from King Fritz. As far as we know, King Fritz and Ymir have three daughters. Thus should not all Eldians be also descendent of King Fritz? This only make sense if Ymir had kids with some-one else, other than King Fritz, but that is not shown. What am I missing? Or is it a plot hole?

To rephrase it. We know Ymir only obey commands of the royal family and that why founding titan can only be used by those of the royal family. But if all eldians are her descendants, and she only had children with royal King Fritz, all eldians should be Fritz. But that is not the case, why?

1

All Subjects of Ymir are Eldians, but not all Eldians are Subjects of Ymir or Royal.

Technically, every subject of Ymir has Royal blood, but it is not enough to make an impact. Remember, King Fritz was just a human and his bloodline can be diluted to the point where Ymir does not recognize it and all subjects are connected through Paths so that can not be diluted. Only one of the 3 daughters was kept as the Queen of Eldia and kept the Royal Family bloodline as pure as possible (possibly through incest, IDK. Historia was not a result of incest so it is a bit confusing). The other 2 were used as breeding machines to create more subjects of Ymir, diluting the Royal blood immensely.

1

I'm going to go with the original poster and claim this as a plot hole. Every Subject of Ymir should be able to trace their lineage directly back to Ymir and the first King Fritz. Incest isn't mentioned and Fritz's last wish for his daughters was to reproduce as much as possible to pass down the Titan's power. This would mean the daughters would need to take "lowborn" husbands to pass on the bloodline. Again, incest isn't mentioned, so Fritz's grandchildren would also take commoners as mates (male or female), so forth and so on with every generation. With Fritz and Ymir as the progenitors for ALL subjects of Ymir and excluding incest (since it isn't mentioned), I can't think of a way for the royal bloodline to be so indistinguishable enough for the Founding Titan's power to be passed down only through a specific lineage. For all intents and purposes, every Ymir Subject is as much of a cousin to the next and any Ymir Subject should (theoretically) be able to use the Founding Titan's power. Unless it's passed down through the male lineage, but Fritz didn't have any sons. Unless it's passed through the female lineage, but what would make a daughter from Sheena more apt to the Founding Titan's powers than a daughter from Maria, since they are both direct descendents from Ymir/Fritz? Unless it's passed down through the Fritz's ruling line of succession, but that's just through a naming convention to where, if that were the case, then the FT's power simply follows a named successor (and that's just silly). Hmm, my last point may very well be the case of how the bloodline remains "distinctly Fritz" - in name only, I guess.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.