13

In Dragonball Z, when Gohan changed into an Ozoro, Piccolo found an appropriate solution, destroy the moon. Easy-peasy.

The real question is, when Goku used his Genki Dama (on two occasions, by the way), it never resulted in anything more than a relatively small crater. With all the power stored inside that sphere (easy above a billion, and over 9000), shouldn't it have caused a bit more damage? Piccolo managed to destroy the moon, easily, with power level of less than 1000.

  • Is the title supposed to be metaphor? – atlantiza Dec 17 '12 at 21:53
  • @atlantiza At first I was confused lol – Alenanno Dec 17 '12 at 21:56
  • @Alenanno Me too. If it is a metaphor it might be best to change it. I clicked on the question because I didn't know Dragonball had dinosaurs. – atlantiza Dec 17 '12 at 21:58
  • 1
    @atlantiza Ah wait, Dragon Ball has dinosaurs. :D – Alenanno Dec 17 '12 at 22:00
  • @Alenanno Also to DragonBall z. (when Piccolo trained Gohan) – Hashirama Senju Dec 17 '12 at 22:03
17

Piccolo isn't the only character to blow up the moon in Dragon Ball. Master Roshi (disguised as Jackie Chun) destroys the moon at the end of the 21st World Martial Arts Tournament using the MAX Power Kamehameha, which takes considerably more effort than for Piccolo. In the meantime, Kami recreated the moon, so this isn't a plot hole.

However, it's a good question as to why the moon is so easy to destroy, while the earth is so much harder. Part of this can be explained since the moon is much less massive, but even then the numbers don't quite add up if we assume the Earth and Moon are the same as ours. Let's assume that physics in the DB universe is at least somewhat similar to our own, modulo spirit attacks and whatever else. Of course, this assumption might be wrong, but if you start changing how physics works, there's no reason why the moon can't be filled with TNT so that it explodes whenever anyone so much as looks at it.

I've made some approximations in the following calculations. I calculated the gravitational binding energy of the moon to be 1.2 * 10^29 J. That's the minimum amount of energy to blow up the moon so that it won't reform by its own gravity, so we can assume that the characters were using at least that much energy. That amount would be enough to knock 3.4 * 10^20 kg of matter off of the surface of the earth, which is roughly 0.006% of the mass of the earth. That doesn't seem like a lot, but if we assume a uniform density of the earth, that's about 1.6 * 10^7 cubic miles of matter, which corresponds to a cube where each side has length 250 miles. That's a pretty huge crater. So just saying that the moon is easier to blow up than the earth isn't going to cut it.

There are 3 ways to resolve this. First, the earth and moon in the DB universe could be very different from what they are here. Specifically, the moon could be larger and less massive, and the earth smaller and more massive than in real life. However, it takes quite a bit of stretching to get believable values, and that's ignoring the vast power difference between DBZ Goku and DB Roshi. If you push things that far, I wouldn't expect it to be consistent with everything else in the series. The second possibility is that the moon is somehow more vulnerable than the Earth to attacks. This is roughly what Alenanno's answer says. It's entirely possible, but as far as I can tell there's little indication of this in the series apart from the Genki Dama, so I don't know why other attacks directed at planets would not destroy them.

This leaves the third possibility, which is my personal choice: the producers weren't really thinking about it when they did this, and were more concerned with making things dramatic than making them consistent. As such, I'd call this a plot hole, but it's a pretty minor one in the grand scheme of things.

  • I think option #3 is the most plausible. Thanks for your answer! – Madara Uchiha Dec 18 '12 at 15:25
  • I take option 4, They did not want to blow up the planet with their attacks, so they learned how to contain the explosions. This would allow them to control the size of the destruction, and has the added bonus of condensing the damage to a smaller area, hence more of it to a humanoid target. After all, The same amount of energy over a larger area means less energy in the smaller area that is the target. This would also explain why small shots pierce (high energy in small area), and why punching is still valid (being efficiently contained in the fist) – Ryan Mar 28 '16 at 20:23
7

Simple answer, Piccolo WANTED to destroy the moon. It has been demonstrated on numerous occasions that the characters in DBZ have a very exact control over their energy. The best option for how to look at it is that Goku when using the Spirit Bomb on Frieza didn't want to destroy Namek because it would kill him and his friends, the best explanation is that he concentrated the energy of the explosion almost entirely on Frieza. As for when it was used on Buu, at that point the bomb was not only concentrated on Buu but was also being fired at an angle (as evidenced by it pushing Buu backwards) so it can be assumed that the reason it only left a crater that time was because very little of the bomb's energy was focused on the planet. This is just my own speculation but if you wanted a reason then this would be your best one as trying to explain it in other ways leads towards more questions and even more speculation as to the powers of the characters.

  • Underrated answer, IMO. Self-control is a very important virtue that you would expect an expert (good or pure-hearted might be a requirement also) warrior to have (hence why it seems like every DBZ villain does great until they lose their cool). Therefore it's pretty reasonable to assume that both Goku and Piccolo (at least, post-Dragon Ball Piccolo) have fine enough control over their ki to decide whether or not they wanted to destroy the moon with a given attack. Of course that opens up a whole can of worms involving SSJ... but then again the Kaio-ken is a testament to Goku's self-control. – Lucas Leblanc Aug 4 '15 at 17:35
4

The Genki Dama (元気玉, Spiritual Energy Sphere) cannot be created by someone with an impure heart and mind. This implies that you use it against evil. It's positive energy that you use to get rid of the evil that is poisoning your world.

Still, this does not mean the Genki Dama is not powerful enough to destroy a planet. After all, King Kai says:

[...] If you can draw so much destructive power from a ball made on this small planet... ...Imagine what you can do with a Spirit Ball formed on Earth! If you can also learn to tap into the astounding powers of the Sun... Well. Just be careful. Or you may destroy the very planet you're trying to protect!"

So I suppose this means that Goku gets just the energy necessary to kill Frieza (or whoever was there) and not the planet itself. He's Goku after all, he supposedly can control his energy.

Piccolo doesn't have such a limit. He intentionally destroys the Moon with pure, mindless power.

2

Well, there is no physical evidence to that,
But Namek was approximately the size of Earth and the Moon probably was much more smaller.
so basically it was easier for Piccolo to do so.

  • You're forgetting Goku was about 1000 times stronger than Piccolo at that point. – Madara Uchiha Dec 18 '12 at 15:23
  • According to TeamFourStar Dragon Ball Z Abridged youtube series, powerlevels are bullsh!t. – Nil May 7 '13 at 5:12
0

The simplest explanation I can think of is density.

Earth has an average density of 5.52 g/cm. The moon has an average density of 3.34 g/cm.

So, it's possible that the difference is exponential - the difference may be only 2.18 g/cm, but the force needed to blow something up may increase from a (arbitrary numbers here) threshold of 100 (moon) to a threshold of 1000, instead of a threshold from 100 to, say, 300.

  • Goku was about 5-6 orders of magnitude stronger than Piccolo at that stage. I don't think that applies here :P – Madara Uchiha Jul 10 '13 at 10:34

protected by nhahtdh Aug 3 '15 at 17:39

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.