4

Rem warned Light not to hurt Misa or it would kill Light by writing his name in it's Deathnote, but Ryuk had mentioned in the last episode as well as before that either Ryuk would kill Light or that Light would die after living his natural lifespan. As Ryuk has to kill him, was Rem's warning a bluff?

If so, couldn't Light, being a genius, see through his bluff??

  • I could have sworn Ryuk said that he would write Light's name down in the Death Note when he is at his end - to prevent Light from going to heaven. I think Ryuk was trying to iterate the point that Light's death will be by Death Note, whether it is by himself or any other shinigami. – krikara Dec 27 '13 at 1:30
  • Just based on REM killing L, isn't it obvious she could've killed Light/Kira as well? Both L and Kira were humans... REM a shinigami... – user9056 Nov 7 '14 at 3:49
10

Rem warned Light, but later Misa told Rem not to harm him, that she would rather die first. So Rem, in order to preserve Misa's happiness,couldn't kill him.

Light, being a genius, learned how to take advantage of the situation, and used Rem on his plans, manipulating her like any other.

  • but initially Rem did threaten Light.. so was Rem bluffing at that point of time? – Adeetya Dec 27 '13 at 2:28
  • 3
    @Adeetya It wasn't a bluff. If Light was going to get Misa killed, Rem would have killed Light. That is why Light needed to keep Misa alive and thus created the great plan where L would write down Misa's name in the note. Rem was then forced to kill L and sacrifice her own life. – krikara Dec 27 '13 at 7:53
  • @Adeetya When Rem warned Light, she meant it. Then, Light outsmarted her. Anyway, as krikara pointed, Light never tried to kill Misa, so Rem never had the occasion to prove her threats. – Flamma Dec 27 '13 at 10:05
5

Chapter 30

Rem threatens Light by saying

If you try to harm this girl, I will write your name in my note and kill you.

enter image description here

Chapter 57

Six months after Rem threatens Light, the killing spree has begun again as soon as Misa was released. Because of this L assumes correctly that Misa is the second killer. Rem knows that if she doesn't take action Misa will be killed soon and she also realizes that this is exactly what Light had planned. Therefore she considers killing Light as she had stated six months earlier, but by now she realizes she can't kill him. Her statement wasn't a bluff, she just realizes that there would be no point on killing Light. On the contrary, and I quote:

With this, killing Yagami Light means nothing. Misa cannot be saved.. More than that, Misa will be lost as an ally and I will be driven more quickly into a corner... No. I already know that if Yagami Light dies, then Misa will lose all will to live. Yagami Light is already a human who is in many ways, necessary for Misa to continue living...

enter image description here

Rem had played her cards well, but Light played better. He had completely manipulated the situation, resulting in the death of a Death God. If Rem wanted to save Misa, she had to kill L and had to do so quickly. As much as she might have hated Light, killing him would result in the complete opposite of what she wanted and would make her death an utterly useless sacrifice.

1

There is a rule in How To Read 13 that states "Only a God of Death that has passed on their Death Note to a human is able to kill the owner of the Death Note." This means that Rem could only kill Light if he was the owner her second Death Note. It was either a bluff or a mistake. Rule 34 item 3:

Only a god of death that has passed on their Death Note to a human is able to kill the owner of the Death Note.

0

In How to Read XXXIV, the third point reads,

Only a god of death that has passed on their Death Note to a human is able to kill the owner of the Death Note.

that means ryuk is the only on who could killed light yagami

  • Where did you get that bolded line from, either way this is false as if it was true Light would have been unable to kill Kyosuke Higuchi in Episode 23 - Frenzy who was the owner of Ryuk's Death Note at the time (in which Light held onto it untill Kyosuke died to become the next owner) – Memor-X Jun 29 '14 at 22:35
  • it's a rule of the death note. – DarkYagami Jun 30 '14 at 18:03
  • Ahhh, i found it, How to Read XXXIV, the rule would seem to cover only interaction between Shinigami so my earlier evidence is incorrect, however remember that Light's Death Note is not Ryuk's but Sidoh's which was stolen so it was never "pass on" to Light – Memor-X Jun 30 '14 at 23:20
  • 1
    i retract my previous comments, according to here and here while the Death Note Light was using at the time Rem threatened him was actually Sidoh's, Ryuk had claimed ownership by tricking the Shinigami King, so the remaining question is if Ryuk had technically passed it onto Light, if so, at that time Rem can't kill Light – Memor-X Jul 2 '14 at 2:30
  • 1
    It says that an owner of the Death Note can only be killed by a god of death who has passed on their Death Note to a human. Rem took ownership of Gelus's Death Note and passed it onto Misa, which meets the criteria presented in that rule. It doesn't specifically say that the god of death can only kill the human who received their Death Note. – Azrael Jul 2 '14 at 5:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.